Legionnaires #44

Legionnaires #44 (1997)
written by Tom Peyer & Tom McCraw
pencils and cover by Jeff Moy

We barely had the time to meet the rookies last time, but they’ll get their chance to shine.

After Lori Morning gets her birthday. I wonder how did the Legion even found out it was her birthday, their information of the 20th century doesn’t seem to be THAT precise… it’s more likely she just told them.

She might not have told them the correct year, though.

Everyone is happy for her, except Umbra. This is our first good look at her personality, and spoiler alert: she’s rarely happy. About anything.

There’s a part of the Legion fandom that really can’t stand Lori Morning.
And I get it… she’s SUPPOSED to be annoying, and the book focuses on her a little too much to the detriment of some Legionnaires. But I actually like her as a character.
I could’ve done without the whole subplot about the 11 year old tying to Rond Vidar jealous.
It’s easy to forget that Rond is ALSO a teenager, but still… yeesh.

Umbra’s first shown character trait is being a very negative person.
Magno’s first shown character trait is being hit on by an 11 year old attempting to make a teenage boy jealous.
First Magnetic Kid, now Magno, what is it with Braalians who are not Cosmic Boy ending up in subplots where they’re awkward around women?

Rond’s birthday present is reverting Lori back to her true biological age.

She doesn’t take this well.

That’s made infinitely worse by the Athramites, who have a new costume for Lori.

Also: new reaction meme just dropped.

The whole incident doesn’t win Rond any points with the team.

I think the Legionnaires are being a bit too harsh on Ron, since he does have a point: Lori clearly wasn’t dealing with her new status in a healthy way and restoring to her regular body was definitely the right thing to do.
On the other hand, there HAD to be a better way to make her understand the change.

He does have a way to get back in the Legion’s good graces.

Live Wire is dealing with more serious business right now.
Also, a reminder that Sensor is NOT eligible for the “Moy tongue” counter: every penciler draws her sticking her tongue out. It’s not a quirky running gag, that’s how her biology works.

Umbra’s other character trait is having an extremely high opinion of herself.
That attitude robs several Shadow Lass fans the wrong way, but this is one of the things that makes Umbra my favorite version of the character: you know I’m a sucker for the “insufferable teammate that slowly learns to trust others” trope.
With the exception of Dawnstar because I don’t feel she ever grew out of being stuck-up.

Thanks to Rond Vidar, the 30th century Legionnaires are finally able to communicate with their time-lost friends. We’ll actually see this exact scene from the other perspective in the main book.
Don’t pay attention to why Brainiac 5 has a monkey on his shoulder, it will ALMOST make sense there.

Not really the moment for that, Chameleon.

This is where the 20th century team gets the confirmation that Leviathan really IS dead.

The connection doesn’t last long.
Live Wire and XS are waaaay too quick to jump to the conclusion that Cosmic Boy and Saturn Girl are a couple now… they saw them for what, maybe a minute? Seeing Cosmic Boy console her after she learned about a friend dying feels like quite the jump.
I mean they’re right, but it feels like they glimpsed at the script there.

We’ll return to the topic at the end of the issue, but now it’s time for the main plot.

Nice contrast between Umbra and Sensor: the princess is actually the humble one.

Sensor is actually one of the kindest Legionnaires, so her dealing the final blow should tell you how much Umbra needs character development.

You might be wondering: how is dealing with a cave-in going to carry a whole issue?

This is a trap set by some villains who are ALSO not fond of dealing with the rookies.
Who will soon learn were rejected in the latest audition, so…
Rejected members: 17

Neat bit of character work here: all three rookies have a very different reaction to seeing the mines.
Although what we will eventually learn about Sensor’s planet doesn’t entirely fit her comment.

Considering that Sensor’s first contribution to the mission is thanks to her knowledge of tongues… is this the most Jeff Moy story so far?

I mean if you told me there was a supervillain whose power is sticking out his tongue, I would immediately think “that’s a Jeff Moy character”.

Also, for the exact reason of Sensor, I am NOT going to count every single panel where Tongue sticks out his tongue.
Especially because his power is… uhm… what’s a good representation of the effect it solicits?

This interaction raises soooo many questions.
1) Is French wide-spoken enough for a Talokian who just came to Earth to notice?
2) WHY???
3) What does Interlac with a French accent sound like?
4) BUT WHY???  

Also, Tongue’s power isn’t just a prehensile tongue (which he can evidently use while still talking)… it’s a SHAPESHIFTING prehensile tongue.

Umbra, I don’t want to tell you ANYTHING about that guy.

I can’t believe Tongue gets the most panels out of the villains, considering Density has a FAR more useful power. She’s like an actually useful version of Stone Boy.

Although I don’t think either of these would have passed the final exam, as both don’t seem to be very good under pressure.

A better final test: tell the applicants they might have to fight Tongue.
If they refuse, they’re out of the Legion.
If they enthusiastically accept, they’re also out of the Legion.

It’s interesting to see Umbra fighting Cherry Bomb, since her power is basically the opposite of creating shadows.

Tongue’s greatest advantage is that in order to defeat him you have to touch his tongue.
Which means you also automatically lose.

I think the Legion Constitution needs an upgrade after this story.
In addition to authorizing lethal force for self-defense, it should also allow lethal force if your opponent traps you in a net made of tongues.

Umbra’s sense of superiority doesn’t exactly come out of nowhere.

We also discover that the cave-in exposed a long-lost tomb with the letters MORD carved in.
Eh, that’s probably not important.

We could end the story there, but we circle back to the Lori plot by having a bit of gossip.

It’s not out of nowhere: this is some character growth for XS, who learns to leave her crush behind.
Don’t feel bad for her, she’ll get new crushes.

Speaking of crushes, we’re definitely past Lori being into Rond Vidar.


Legion significance: 6/10
You might expect this issue to be the last contribution of Lori, but her storyline has just started.
The biggest influence is the Legionnaires learning where their teammates are; this won’t be their last interaction prior to their return.
And of course there’s that secret tomb. I wonder if that’s going to become important in a giant storyline that culminates in issue 50?

Silver Age-ness: 10/Tongue
An alien with a French accent and a shapeshifting tongue!!!


Does it stand the test of time? 9/10
A lot of your enjoyment of this issue will depend on your tolerance of Lori, your opinions on Umbra, and your tolerance for tongue shenanigans.
I’m fine with the first, I love the second, and the third was getting tiresome by the end.
Jokes aside, this was pretty solid: we get varied reactions about the situation of the lost Legionnaires, and a good first impression of the rookies.
My only complains are that the Lori situation could’ve used a bit more tact, that figuring out the Cosmic Boy & Saturn Girl relationship so fast was ridiculous, and that the mission should’ve given SOMETHING to do to poor Magno.
But they’re all minor nitpicks that don’t ruin the enjoyment of the story, which I feel can be mostly done today with no changes.
Now I hope I never see a shapeshifting tongue ever again.

Moy Tongues: 25
Amazingly for the most tongue story ever, since I’m not counting either Sensor or Tongue we have only one addition.


Who did it better?
Umbra nicknames the villains the “Legion of Super-Rejects”, which is a direct reference to Superboy #212. I don’t think it’s fair to compare the two stories though, given the focus is completely different.
What I can compare is Phantom Lad, who is the only character to appear in both stories.
The look of the Reboot version is extremely derivative of Apparition’s, but ANYTHING is better than his original costume.



We are legion

I’m a bit torn whether I should still consider the time-traveling Legionnaires under the “missing in action” category. But considering that at this point the Legion knows both that they are alive and exactly where and when they are, I’m moving all of them back to “active” status… they’re just active in another time period.

  • 19 active Legionnaires
  • 1 missing in action (Shrinking Violet)
  • 1 resigned member (Andromeda)
  • 1 honorary member (Superboy)
  • 2 deceased members (Kid Quantum and Leviathan)
  • 24 people have been members
  • 4 Legion leaders (Leviathan, Cosmic Boy, Shrinking Violet, Live Wire)
  • 17 members have been rejected

Interesting letters: Lori was indeed initially conceived as eventually becoming Glorith, so I get the readers anticipating it.
But Rond Vidar turning into Mordru? Where did THAT come from!?

Still more interesting than making him a Green Lantern, though.