The Ghost Rider #1 (1967)
written by Gary Friedrich & Roy Thomas
pencils and cover by Dick Ayers
It’s been a while since cowboys showed un in the hero retrospective, and we have reached the final Marvel hero in the cowboy era. Who is simultaneously the most superhero-adjacent AND the most distant.
![]()
But before we do that, we first have to address the horse in the room.
Because not only we’re not talking about the more famous Ghost Rider… he’s not even the first Ghost Rider in comics.
That honor goes to a hero who debuted in 1949 on the pages of Tim Holt #11 by Magazine Enterprises.
Not being a fan of western this is the first time I heard of the actor Tim Holt… how famous is he totay in America?
![]()
In any case, it’s bizarre to me that they published a comic book with the name of a cowboy actor that also included adventures of other cowboys.
Also: the actor died in 1973, one year after the debut of the flaming skull hero, so in his lifetime there were THREE distinct debuts for a Ghost Rider.
![]()
The 1949 Ghost Rider is worth mentioning in this review for another reason in addition to the name: he was also co-created by Dick Ayers.
![]()
He didn’t even start as “Ghost Rider” but as the far more generic “Rex Fury, the Calico Kid”.
But when he was believed dead, he created the Ghost Rider persona by covering himself in phosphorus (!!!) to scare his villains to death.
![]()
LITERALLY in some cases.
![]()
Ghost Rider went in to have several stories, both on Tim Holt and on his own serie, which even had covers by Frank Frazetta. Yes, that one.
![]()
Information on him isn’t easy to find, but the last appearance of this Ghost Rider dates back to 1955: Magazine Enterprises ceased publications, and the character ended up in public domain.
AC Comics reprinted his original stories, under the name “Haunted Horseman” since at this point Marvel had a lock on the “Ghost Rider” trademark.
And if he was a woman I’m certain that he would’ve joined Femforce.
![]()
Which of course means HIS DAUGHTER joins Femforce…
![]()
…as “Buckaroo Betty”.
There are two huge differences from her father.
![]()
By which I mean that she’s a time traveler and that she briefly had actual superpowers by becoming the new Hood (no relation to the Marvel one… I pray) for a couple of issues.
What did you think I meant?
![]()
Just imagine: if Marvel hadn’t taken the Ghost Rider trademark, THIS might be the character most associated with the name.
![]()
But with the original Ghost Rider now in public domain, in 1967 there was no stopping Dick Ayers to bring back his old creation.
And so we begin with teacher Carter Slade fighting Native Americans.
![]()
However it turns out that these are actually white men pretending to be a racial stereotype.
![]()
Carter SHOULD be dead, but a kid brings him to some actual natives.
![]()
He’s either cured or quite possibly resurrected by the tribe.
![]()
His arrival was foretold by the spirits, who also granted the medicine man access to a strange dust that makes him glow.
AMAZINGLY, this won’t turn out to be radioactive!!!
![]()
He’s also given a “ghost-horse”, which I am incredibly disappointed to learn is not an actual ghost but just a white horse.
![]()
Marvel was notoriously reticent to have teenage sidekicks (since Stan Lee never liked the idea), so the kid is just adopted instead of becoming a hero.
![]()
He basically has the same gimmick of the previous Ghost Rider, but the mask makes all the difference… I can can kind of see this working.
![]()
No wonder Dick Ayers resurrected the concept. It’s an incredibly simple design, but man can Ghost Rider look cool.
![]()
Bet you didn’t expect this old west story to be about a real estate scheme mixed with hate crimes!
![]()
I was fully expecting the people to fall for this, but nope: the SECOND they hear these guys talk, they immediately figure out they’re white people.
![]()
Incredibly stupid white people, I might add.
![]()
This leads to, what else, a Big Dumb Ghost Gunfight.
![]()
I imagine this could become repetitive in an ongoing series, but it’s a pretty badass introduction.
![]()
The original Ghost Rider would 100% have murdered these people, but the Comics Code is in full effect right now so he doesn’t even have a gun yet.
![]()
Historical significance: 4/10
Despite not really being linked to the other more famous Ghost Rider, the original version managed to get his own legacy. Too bad it’s not exactly widespread.
Silver Age-ness: 2/10
There was A LOT of potential Silver Age-ness here, from the risk of either voluntary or accidental racism, to linking the glowing dust to radioactivity or alien or magic… and somehow the comic managed to stay clear of all of them!
Does it stand the test of time? 8/10
You’re probably tired of me repeating that I’m not into Westerns, so the fact that I ended up actually liking the story should be high praise.
It still feels dated in a lot of parts, from Carter somehow surviving to the shoehorn kid.
But the action scenes hold up remarkably well, and for once I think that the modern recoloring actually does a favor to the story: the truly black background really helps Ghost Rider stand out in a way that I don’t think works to the same level on paper.
Play up the ambiguity of whether Carter actually died or not, ditch the kid (or give him something to do) and make the bandits actually threatening, and this can actually work today.
How close is this to the modern character? What modern character?
The series wasn’t exactly a hit, lasting only 7 issues. Despite what continuity insert may lead you to believe, he doesn’t have crossovers with the other Marvel western heroes.
![]()
He also appears in the anthology Western Gunfighters, when in 1971 the original Ghost Rider dies in issue 7.
![]()
It’s also the issue where the kid from the origin story becomes the second Ghost Rider…
![]()
…only to die IN THE SAME ISSUE, making Lincoln Slade (the brother of the original) the THIRD Ghost Rider.
![]()
![]()
If you see the other Western heroes interacting with Ghost Rider, there’s a 99% chance it’s the third one, brother of the first.
It’s the same one that meets the time-traveling Avengers in 1975… but by that time there was already a more famous Ghost Rider around, so he was renamed Night Rider.
![]()
The name doesn’t stick, and the character is retroactively renamed Phantom Rider.
We will see Lincoln Slade again in 1987 in an infamous story that Marvel would probably prefer we’d forget. In a West Coast Avengers storyline, he kidnaps a time-traveling Mockingbird and gives her a potion that makes her forget her past (!!!) and fall in love with him (!!!).
Yeah, Lincoln wasn’t exactly right in the head at this point.
![]()
She eventually recovers her memories and ends up killing Phantom Rider as revenge for… well the comic doesn’t go as far as say it out loud, but he unmistakenly raped her.
![]()
We’ll get back to Lincoln Slade in a moment.
But already in 1981, Ghost Rider v2 #56 introduced a 20th century version: Hamilton Slade, direct descendant of Lincoln Slade.
Originally called Night Rider because the Phantom Rider retcon hadn’t been established yet.
![]()
The reason why I say that Marvel probably wants you to forget the 1987 storyline isn’t necessarily because Mockingbird was raped.
But because it leads to a second storyline where Lincoln Slade possesses his descendant…
![]()
…and tells Hawkeye about what happened.
Leading to Hawkeye TRUSTING THE MAN WHO RAPED HIS WIFE and breaking up with her!!!
![]()
Steve Englehart is a comic book legend that has written countless masterpieces.
This was NOT one of them.
![]()
In 2008 we learned about a different family branch, when we meet J.T. Slate: a descendant of the FIRST Phantom Rider, Carter Slate. He ended up joining the Secret Warriors… where he had the power to conjure up chains made of hellfire.
I can’t stress enough that the old west Ghost Rider has NOTHING TO DO WHATSOEVER with the motorcycle guy OR with hellfire.
Brian Michael Bendis just took the concept of “descendant of the old west Ghost Rider” and apparently NOBODY told him that this makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.
![]()
Not that it matters that much; he was unceremoniously killed off in 2010 on Secret Warriors, although he did manage to have a counterpart in the Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. TV series.
I loved that show and I completely forgot the counterpart existed until this review.
The mistake was probably inspired by the fact that the 2007 Ghost Rider movie DOES have a Carter Slate as a flaming skull Ghost Rider but still… come on, was NOBODY editing the Bendis books???
![]()
Hamilton Slade would keep his position as Phantom Rider (after getting rid of the ghost possessing him) until 2010, where he’s killed in Hawkeye & Mockingbird #10.
Appropriately, he’s killed by Hawkeye and Mockingbird villain Crossfire while trying to exorcise Lincoln Slade.
![]()
The mantle has been taken by his daughter Jaime Slade.
We went full circle with the Magazine Enterprises version because she also doesn’t have a mask.
![]()
She starts out as being possessed by the spirit of Lincoln Slade before the aforementioned exorcism, so… yeah the old west version is irredeemable on multiple levels at this point.
![]()
Jaime has not been seen since this 2010 miniseries and she wasn’t herself when she was acting as Phantom Rider.
![]()
But I kind of hope someone remembers the character and brings her back: she had a cool design and we really, really, REALLY need to leave the cowboy ghost rapist behind.
Phantom Rider will never be more popular than the flaming skeleton Ghost Rider, but I firmly believe there’s a place for a spooky white ghost cowboy superhero.
![]()
At the very least, this version of Phantom Rider was better than Buckaroo Betty for two very big reasons.
She has a better costume and a better name, what did you think I meant?
![]()
And if you have to do a flashback with western superheroes… either use Carter Slate or bring back Reno Jones: the 1972 character that became Ghost Rider during 2000’s Blaze Of Glory miniseries.
I will take the former slave taking up the mantle over the cowboy ghost rapist any day.
![]()