Superman v2 119 (1996)
by Dan Jurgens & Ron Frenz
Superman is far from done interacting with the Legion during its 20th century stay.
![]()
And he begins the team-up with some fanservice.
![]()
Great save Clark, no notes.
![]()
The reason for this suntanning session is that after Superman lost his powers during Final Night, they didn’t come back even after the Sun returned to full power.
Complaining with a man with cancer how tough it is to no longer be a god kind of makes him feel bad.
![]()
While it’s not super relevant to this story, at this point Clark and Lois have married.
And they’re not the only ones: not only Lex Luthor married a few months earlier, but this is the story when he learns he’s going to have a daughter.
That’s going to play a small part in the final stretch of the Legion visit.
![]()
This story has a bit of significance for me. Because Superman at this time WAS being regularly translated in Italy on his own Play Press series, this was one of my earliest exposures to the Reboot Legion.
I had already seen them during the Final Night miniseries, but this time they’re going to play a major role.
![]()
At no point during any of the team-ups I ever got the impression that Inferno was anything but a regular Legionnaire.
![]()
The Legion was trying to sneak into a secret facility to gather advanced technology, but they were unexpectedly discovered.
![]()
Uhm, Shvaughn, this is the 20th century Metropolis. These guys probably have to deal with superpowers and aliens more often than 30th century Metropolis.
![]()
Especially because the place the Legion is trying to raid belongs to Lexcorp.
![]()
Brainiac 5 absolutely means this as a heartfelt compliment.
![]()
Brainiac 5 was correct: the Legion didn’t commit any mistakes in their infiltration.
It was Superman who tripped the alarm.
![]()
Superman needs to borrow Luthor’s spaceship, and he does so coming up with both an excuse and an unexpected continuity callout.
![]()
Yep, this story establishes that the Superman/Aliens miniseries is actually canon.
There’s also a bit of a thematic connection, since Superman was powerless throughout most of that miniseries. Which of course he was, otherwise it would’ve lasted 3 panels instead of 3 issues.
Even weirder: that’s actually a GOOD story that I recommend checking out.
![]()
Also, this has nothing to do with the story, but I’m sure that if I don’t talk about it someone would bring it up in the comments. That is the miniseries where Superman teams up with the sole survivor of a space colony that should look slightly familiar.
![]()
She survives the miniseries (although Superman doesn’t know it), but sadly she never comes back. I assume less because there was another Supergirl flying around and more because of licensing trouble. Too bad, because this version of Kara was AWESOME.
![]()
What was I talking about? Oh, right, this is a Legion review.
![]()
Just in case you need a reminder of just how smarter Brainiac 5 is supposed to be.
![]()
Brainy, you’ve been complaining non-stop about having to work with primitive technology, and the only one you feel like helping with that is Lex Luthor!?
![]()
As much as I love this version of Brainiac 5, I have to agree with Superman… the gag of complaining about primitive tech is already overused.
![]()
I remind you that Superman is one of the very few heroes who know the Legion is from the future, everyone else assumes they’re just aliens.
![]()
Never change, Brainiac 5, never change.
![]()
The Sun-Tanner 50,000™ works as intended…
![]()
…but something’s wrong with Superman, and the process fails.
![]()
The story definitely hints at something truly unexpected interfering with all attempts to restore Superman’s powers.
![]()
Lex has figured out that Superman is powerless, but that’s a problem for HIS books and outside of the scope of this retrospective.
![]()
Legion significance: 0/10
It does have some significance for Superman because it’s where we learn Lex is going to have a kid, but for the Legion it’s not even a footnote.
You’re definitely better off tracking the Superman/Aliens miniseries.
Silver Age-ness: 2/10
There is a hint of a big reason for why Brainiac 5’s plan didn’t work. The fact that it’s never addressed in a satisfying matter (later on that below) makes it a little bit Silver Age.
Does it stand the test of time? 8/10
Jurgens can probably write Superman in his sleep at this point; the story is fine if nothing spectacular, and the dialogue is good. He also seems to have a rather good grasp of the Legionnaires, because the few dialogue they get does feel in-character.
What holds it back in my opinion is the artwork. Ron Frenz is a good artist but I feel he’s a bad match for Superman, especially with Joe Rubinstein inking.
From a personal perspective, this was a pretty good introduction to the team dynamics. I was initially wondering why Apparition is absent, but then I remembered she’s currently a ghost that only Ultra Boy and Saturn Girl can see unless the latter uses her telepathy… and what good would have been making Superman be able to see her?
“Don’t call me Brainy”: 9
![]()
All this talk about something interfering with Superman’s powers had me thinking, though, because I didn’t remember the explanation given by the time he *spoiler alert* gets his powers back.
He does it four issues later, after diving into the Sun under the instructions of Metron of the New Gods.
![]()
We’re pretty close to the storyline where Superman’s powers completely change to energy-based ones (the so-called “Electric Superman” era), so it’s definitely connected.
I went back to have a look at those stories to see if they ever gave an actual in-universe explanation for WHY his powers changed…
![]()
…and the closest I could find is on Adventures of Superman #549.
It’s just a VERY vague callback to Superman interacting with the post-Crisis version of Kandor and linking to the upcoming (and awful) Genesis crossover.
![]()
I didn’t mind the Electric Superman storyline, but being this vague about why Superman’s powers changed so drastically certainly didn’t help it.